Testimonials

“I hired Shay to find an place in Brooklyn and she exceeded my expectations throughout the process. From the beginning I could sense that she was savvy in leveraging technology and a great communicator. Shay was able to understand my needs and we made valuable use of time when we were together. When I found what I wanted, she was quickly on top of things to make sure we got our paperwork completed asap. I was so pleased that she even followed up after our move in to make sure we were satisfied. I think Shay is asset to her industry and I would absolutely hire her again.”

Elaine D., Prospect Heights

“I’ve worked with Shay for the past 4 years, she’s gone above and beyond the call of duty every time I have called on her. She’s detail-oriented, a creative-thinker and a hard worker. I know I’m in great hands with Shay and I am comfortable handing the entire process over to her. She has helped me rent out my apartment twice and in once instance created a bidding war and was able to get me more money in rent than I originally anticipated. It’s been a pleasure to work with Shay. I highly recommend her services.”

Kalyn J., Park Slope

“When I first responded via email to a listing online, Shay called me to follow up within a matter of minutes. From the beginning of my search process through to the closing on my new apartment, Shay continued to be prompt, efficient, and extremely helpful with all of my questions and concerns. Her friendly and professional demeanor really made it a pleasure to work with her.”

Heather B., Brooklyn Heights

“Knowledgeable, diligent, efficient, patient, kind, tactful, perseverant…These are all the personal qualities that Shay showed as my realtor. It was a breath of fresh air to meet a realtor that advertised honestly, was knowledgeable in areas that I was interested in, and most importantly I was impressed with her availability at all times of the day according to my convenience for my house search. Overall I had a great experience with Shay! I highly recommend the services of Shay Mitchell-Peters to anyone and look forward to working with her in the near future.”

Cassandre D., Bedford-Stuyvesant

“I worked with Shay when I purchased my first home and I would definitely use her again. She made the entire process effortless. Shay was extremely professional and worked well with all parties involved.”

Simone C., Fort Greene

“Shay is a treasure! I met her when I needed to leave my current apartment due to personal reasons. I was in a horrible state and wasn’t sure if I could even find a place. Shay was patient and worked with me to find the perfect apartment. I wholeheartedly recommend her services to anyone.”

Shaunna R., Park Slope

“We feel so lucky that we found Shay to help us with our recent apartment search. She is extremely professional and personable, always on time and really made the process easy for us every step of the way. She took the time to get to know us and to understand what we were looking for. With her help, we found an amazing apartment in Carroll Gardens that was exactly what we were looking for. We are recommending her to everyone we know!”

Stephanie and Ryan J., Carroll Gardens

“As you know, entering the New York real estate market is not for the faint of heart. Shay was outstanding in helping me navigate through the rough waters of purchasing the apartment. She always stayed in contact with me, giving me updates and returning my calls, but most of all, it was her personality. She’s genuine, not like some disreputable real estate brokers I have come across. She calmed me down on several occasions when I was flustered by the mortgage broker, managing agent etc. And most of all, she seemed truly happy that we found a place.”

Michael B., Prospect Heights

“I referred Shay to a friend of mine who was beginning his search for his first BK apartment. Amidst all the unfortunate stories he read on blogs, and other bad experiences he had heard of – his search was record breaking, a breeze and he found a fabulous find!! Thanks Shay for your professionalism and great personable work in helping my friend find an apartment in BK!”

Roxann R., Bedford-Stuyvesant

“Shay Mitchell is everything I could have hoped for as my agent and more!  She truly listened and worked hard on my behalf to find what I was looking for. Her attention to detail, follow through, commitment to excellence and work ethic place her is a class all by herself.  She is an excellent communicator who makes certain that any questions or concerns are promptly addressed. Most important, she is honest, warm and caring.”

William W., Park Slope

“Shay made my home searching experience a pleasurable one. She was not only professional but really took the time to understand what I needed. Her experience and efficiency made the entire process stress free. I would certainly use her again.”

Leighton C., Bedford-Stuyvesant